title1261741053
LiveDC: Robyn/ Kelis @ 930 Club
August 4, 2010 | 9:00AM

all photos: Jane Briggs
all words: Svetlana

It is important to note that I walked INTO this show a fan of both Kelis and Robyn, as excited for this show as a teenage girl en route to her first disco.

Further, it is important to note, that I walked OUT of this show a HUGE fan of Robyn and a slightly DISAPPOINTED fan of Kelis. And before anyone goes for my review jugular with fighting screams of “Kelis is AMAZING” let me start at the beginning:

At 8pm the line to get into the sold out show is down the street. I run into a (very nice, very classy) friend of mine and he is wearing glitter all over his face (it is still light outside)

“Hey you, is that glitter all over your face?”

“The real question, Svetlana, is: WHY IS THERE NO GLITTER ALL OVER YOUR FACE?”

Walking in, I see his point. Sometime during the last decade, the combination of Robyn and Kelis became reason enough for a veritable gay dress-up holiday. The club is packed, and glitter on the face is really one of the more subdued way of pledging your undying allegiance to the dance deities everyone is here to see. There’re head dresses, war paint, glow sticks on all body parts and more. It is Monday night, and just like every other Monday, DC IS HERE TO PARTY.

JB, Kelis_080210_0066 JB, Kelis_080210_0062

Kelis is maybe 15 minutes or so late and when she trots out looking like a tall, cool drink of disco it is easy to see why these men LOVE her (as a fellow tall woman who wears glitter dresses a fair amount I can atest to the fine line we walk between fun and drag in those situations). Looking like a life-size Jem doll, clutching her glowing mike, she makes the audience cross their heart and hope to die and promise that they are all here “to dance, and do nothing but dance” and I am excited: THIS IS GOING TO BE GOOD.

JB, Kelis_080210_0049 JB, Kelis_080210_0027 JB, Kelis_080210_0020

And then…IT ISN’T.

You see-she did not sing. In fact-she did not even pretend to sing. She vogued and shimmied and pointed her fingers at things and people and things and people went nuts when she pointed her fingers at them, but overall, it kind of felt like a glorified drag queen lip-sync show (and not a very pro one at that).

She “played” her hits (I was pretty excited to hear at least a portion of “Good Stuff” thrown in) but the decision to also intersperse said hits with dance favorites like “Sweet dreams” resulted in the show feeling like a Kelis dance party in her bedroom, with her singing into a hairbrush and you being allowed to look in. Which, I know, sounds harsh but Kelis-I love you and I had really high hopes for you.

JB, Kelis_080210_0051

Having said that-Did I mention the woman is really super duper insanely HOT? It bears repeating and emphasizing with these photos:

JB, Kelis_080210_0056 JB, Kelis_080210_0032 JB, Kelis_080210_0054

JB, Kelis_080210_0074

Then, a break, emergency vodka runs, anticipation you can cut with a knife (or a feather from your head dress, if you were wearing a head dress) and I look over and say “I hope Robyn does a better job”.

And then Robyn steps out onto the stage, surrounded by her band in crisp white jumpsuits and within exactly 2.5 seconds, all my fears are gone. Robyn is here, and she is here to party. WITH YOU.

JB, Robyn_080210_0067

I have always been a huge fan of the female pop dance stars in their most basic, original form (in fact, if this bill somehow included Roisin Murphy and Annie in it, I could have died a happy woman the next day) and as much as I love the catchy choruses, the crisp production and the mannered images/videos these ladies make, I sometimes worry about what the live show may be like.

There are two ways to go about it: a. make a giant production out of it and try to recreate your record at its most polished or b. just go out and have fun with it.

JB, Robyn_080210_0152 copy

Robyn went with option B. and it could have backfired for all of those expecting her android  chic on Monday night, but, instead, it was AWESOME.

First of all-the woman is a phenomenal dancer. Not a choreographed, technical dancer, but the kind of dancer that you wish YOU WERE DANCING WITH AT A PARTY. The Molly Ringwald leg kicks, the shoulder shimmy shake shakes, the works.

JB, Robyn_080210_0036 JB, Robyn_080210_0060

Second of all-the energy does not let up. It is non-stop, all the time, the kind of energy that makes you feel bad that you’re not as energized.

JB, Robyn_080210_0017

Third of all, for an artists whose work is so produced on record, she really delivers live. The voice is solid over the beats, the hits keep coming (“Dancing on My Own” is a great newish favorite), and while Kelis made you swear that you will do nothing but dance as if she was bringing you into a church of disco, Robyn doesn’t need to make that pretense- it is not a church, it is just a disco (and to keep the energy up, yes, sometimes you do have to eat a banana on stage, we’re all human after all).

JB, Robyn_080210_0194 JB, Robyn_080210_0194 JB, Robyn_080210_0194

Someone make this woman a proper star ASAP (why she isn’t one, and someone like, say, KESHA is, will forever be a mystery to me) so we can all say we saw her at 930 club back when (even though, she’s obviously been on the charts for something like 15 years now and somehow still comes off fresh)

To quote one of my interns on the way out: “How cute was Robyn? I want one!”

JB, Robyn_080210_0081

JB, Robyn_080210_0090 JB, Robyn_080210_0156 JB, Robyn_080210_0090 JB, Robyn_080210_0097 JB, Robyn_080210_0190 JB, Robyn_080210_0195 JB, Robyn_080210_0180

JB, Kelis_080210_0003

Comments:

Your Email Address Will Not Be Published

Recent Comments:
  • Jeff Martin says:

    Janie these are great photos of this show, as good as any that were taken.

  • cale Cale says:

    Yep, that pretty much sums it up.

  • whoa says:

    kelis didn’t singgggggggggggggggg??? say what.
    i must of been to drunk to notice. ha ha

  • Svetlana says:

    I mean, she’d point her mike to the audience and the words kept coming out of the speakers as if she was singing into the microphone. It was pretty much the most blatant lipsyncing of all time.

  • chrisafer says:

    Um, she sang but also had looping backing vocals. She most certainly did sing, though.

  • cale Cale says:

    When she did covers she sang over top of the actual song instead of an instrumental or karaoke or reduced vocal version. She also relied on the looping backing vocals too often.

    Robyn on the other hand had looping backing vocals on some songs and then sang a different part over them, Kelis just sort of sang the same thing on top of them when she felt like it.

  • Come now. says:

    Yeah, she had a backing track. If you’ve ever seen Britney (who is a goddess, obviously), THAT is lip synching. There’s no deviation between the backing vocals and what you hear. Kelis was singing OVER a backing track. She was very clearly singing.

    The only way anyone, iMO, could be disappointed by Kelis, is because Robyn was one of the best live performers I’ve ever seen, whereas Kelis was “just” pretty freaking great.

  • Svetlana says:

    “she just sang on top of them” when she felt like it. my point is that, and I LOVE KELIS (love her), you could not really notice a difference between when she felt like singing over the back up track or when she just let the back up track do ALL THE WORK, which leads me to think that she let the back up track do all the work most of the time (plus, I mean, I saw her not move her mouth and the words to the song (not the back up vocals) were still going on). It does not make me love her records any less, but I am going to call it as I see it.

    Robyn was amazing.

  • cale Cale says:

    Her DJs also made a couple mistakes – even though the dude was obvi really talented. Didn’t understand why the girl DJ was there at all except to just look cool (which is ok).

    I think the point that Svet was trying to make, that I agree with, is that Kelis’ use of backing tracks came off as lazy while others have used them effectively.

    Robyn just destroyed it in every way. Her dancing and energy were unstoppable. Except when it got too late and I went home. What did she do after the first encore song?

  • Gan says:

    She closed out by destroying With Every Heartbeat. Phenomenal, obviously.

  • cale Cale says:

    Ug – was waiting for that the whole night. But it had been a long day and had to be at work early the next day. Thanx Gandolf the Gay.

  • Logan Logan says:

    great review. Kelis definitely felt like a drag show (aided by all the drunken, lispy voices yelling “konichiwa bitchesSsSs!!” during the entire show), but she was super fun. I showed up to dance and have a good time, and her set was sequenced to produce that result. loved when she threw in “my boo” by ghost town djs. anyhow, having no expectations favored my experience.

    I want Robyn to sling me in a bjorn and take me everywhere with her. We can share bananas.

  • Dancing on My Own says:

    Kelis did not sing. Her backing vocals WERE her vocals. Every now and then she would sing a few lines. I watched her from the balcony and though “Is she even going to try to sing at some point.” When she did sing, it was horrible. Thank god for Robyn.

  • Kia says:

    Not everyone is a balls to wall performer. Footwear choices are indicative of such (Robyn’s vs. Kelis’). Kelis has never struck me as the type to go apeshit on stage. Kelis is about looking delicious and having a good time. I thought she was great. She looked AMAZING. And I agree with the person who said her set was created to make you dance. I did not come to this show to scrutinize vocals. I came to wear an avant garde hairstyle that I would sweat out withing 30 mins and shake my ass. Which I did.

    And Robyn – there are no words. I just want to know her. Just want to be in her life.

  • jane says:

    Thanks Jeff and Cale!! I really tried to be on my A game for this show!

  • late to the game says:

    Belated comment of dissent because I’m clearly too cool to read this site regularly: Loved Kelis. She threw a party. Don’t care if she was not really singing. Plus, as stated in the review, she was SUPER hot. I wanted to be her.

    On the other hand, Robyn made us leave early. She danced like she was in a Jane Fonda workout video. Super 80s-ified. And she changing up the music of some of her biggest hits to sound so NOT like I wanted them to sound. I’m all for re-imaginings, but they were slower and more boring versions to the point that I swear I didn’t know what a couple of the songs were until I recognized the lyrics! I appreciated the energy, I really did, but I just couldn’t get behind her set. The schtick just got old.